Skip to content
Procurement Playbook | Smarter Science

Biotech Procurement Solution Comparison: What to Look for and What to Avoid

by ZAGENO
 | 8 min read

Choosing the right biotech procurement solution for your organization isn’t easy. Between marketplace tools, punchout catalogs, P2P systems, ERP-native modules, and specialized platforms like ZAGENO, the options can blur together quickly.

In this article, we break down the most common types of procurement tools used in biotech and life sciences. We’ll show you what to prioritize, what to question, and where the real differences emerge, especially when it comes to integration, usability, supplier access, and support.

Common types of procurement solutions

Before comparing features and platforms, it's important to understand the different types of procurement solutions available. Each category brings its own strengths and limitations when applied to the fast-moving, compliance-sensitive world of biotech.

P2P (Procure-to-Pay) systems: Tools that offer end-to-end procurement capabilities, from requisition to invoice payment. They're strong on compliance, automation, and financial controls, but can be rigid for scientific users and lack deep catalog access for lab-specific needs.

Punchout catalogs: These connect to individual supplier sites through your ERP or procurement system, letting users shop within a vendor’s interface. They often require IT resources to maintain and offer limited visibility or control.

ERP procurement modules: Built directly into ERP systems, these tools focus on financial workflows and compliance, but can be inflexible, hard to navigate, and lacking in scientific supplier coverage.

General marketplace tools: Consumer-style marketplaces may offer broad product selection but lack the scientific filtering, integration, and lab-specific products and features life sciences teams need.

Biotech-specific procurement platforms: Tools like ZAGENO that are purpose-built for R&D-heavy environments. They combine broad supplier access with guided workflows, customer support, and integration designed for complex lab purchases.

Procurement solutions compared

Now that we’ve defined the major types of procurement solutions, here’s a side-by-side comparison to help you evaluate how they stack up across the areas that matter most to biotech organizations.

Feature

Punchout Catalogs

ERP Procurement Module

P2P Systems 

General Marketplace Tool

ZAGENO Biotech Platform

Scientific Supplier Access

Limited, manual add-ons

Narrow, often generic

Moderate, not R&D-specific

Broad but not curated

5,300+ life science suppliers

Ease of Use for Labs

Poor UX, ERP-centric

Finance-focused

Interface not lab-friendly

Moderate, not R&D-specific

Built specifically for life sciences

Guided Buying & Routing

Basic or manual

Custom-coded workflows

Moderate, may need config

Inconsistent

Smart routing by cost center, G/L code, etc., Customizable budget thresholds.

ERP/P2P Integration

Requires IT customization

Built-in for finance use

Native ERP/P2P integration

May need middleware

Seamless integration with major ERPs and P2Ps

Backorder & Order Support

Vendor-dependent

Minimal

Vendor-dependent

Limited

ZAGENO-managed support

Consolidated Cart & Checkout

No

No

No

Often fragmented

Yes. One PO, one invoice, one uniform set of payment terms across all suppliers.

Invoice Matching

Manual or external

Partial automation

Moderate automation

Rare

Automated 3-way matching between POs, invoices, and receipts.

Onboarding New Suppliers

Weeks/months

High IT/admin burden

Varies

Varies

Yes. 2–4 weeks saved on average.

How ZAGENO works with (or without) other systems

ZAGENO is designed to flex around your existing procurement tech stack. Whether you’re using punchout catalogs, an ERP procurement module, or a full-scale P2P platform, ZAGENO can act as your lab-facing layer while syncing cleanly with back-end systems.

  • Using punchouts? ZAGENO consolidates all suppliers into one meta-search and cart, eliminating the need to toggle between vendor-specific punchouts.
  • Using ERP modules? ZAGENO plugs into platforms like SAP and Oracle to extend functionality to the lab without disrupting financial workflows.
  • Running a P2P system? ZAGENO supports native integration to feed POs, invoices, and approval logic directly into your P2P workflows.
  • No system in place yet? ZAGENO can serve as your standalone procurement hub, bringing structure and control without the cost or complexity of a full ERP.

Whether you need a turnkey solution or a modular upgrade to what you already use, ZAGENO brings flexibility and focus to biotech procurement.

What to look for in a platform

When evaluating a biotech procurement platform, prioritize tools that:

  • Support the full R&D procurement workflow, from search to approval to invoice
  • Offer strong ERP integration without extensive IT lift
  • Give scientists the flexibility they need without bypassing policy
  • Provide access to the suppliers, brands, and SKUs your lab actually needs
  • Include hands-on support for backorders, order changes, and vendor communication

Learn more about ZAGENO’s ERP and P2P integrations

What to avoid in a solution

Red flags to watch for:

  • Procurement tools that require your lab users to log in through an ERP interface
  • Limited access to scientific suppliers and niche lab equipment
  • Manual workarounds that persist even after “integration”
  • High dependence on IT teams for updates, onboarding, or reporting
  • One-size-fits-all tools that weren’t built for biotech

Read more: How CPOs Can Lead Through 2025

Why biotech teams choose ZAGENO

ZAGENO was designed specifically for life sciences. That means everything from the vast supplier catalog to approval routing was built with your workflows in mind. Labs get a familiar, searchable interface. Finance and procurement get integration, control, and compliance.

ZAGENO also helps leading biotech teams overcome common procurement bottlenecks, whether they're scaling operations, relocating labs, or simply optimizing day-to-day lab purchasing.

Here are a few real-world outcomes:

And because it’s a true SaaS platform with hands-on support, ZAGENO can scale with you, without overloading IT.

1

See how ZAGENO compares in action.

Request a demo

 

All your lab needs in one place

Access 40,000,000 products in one shop!

Trusted by thousands of scientists, lab managers, procurement and finance teams, ZAGENO's marketplace will help you search and order quickly in one go. Reach out for a demo today!

Read On